“They Would Not Permit us to Work the Coals”

Indigenous Origins of Treaty Making on Canada’s West Coast

Authors

DOI:

https://doi.org/10.14288/bcs.no231.201703

Keywords:

British Colonialism, Indigenous History, Vancouver Island Treaties, Douglas Treaties, British Columbia History, Kwakiutl, WSANEC, Songhees, Sneymuxw

Abstract

This article reframes the story of the Vancouver Island (Douglas) Treaties away from something offered by the Hudson’s Bay Company or the British Crown. Instead, it demonstrates that these were agreements demanded by the Indigenous people of Vancouver Island. The Kwakiutl, WSANEC and Sneymuxw insistence on their ownership, which we document in the treaty period, was part of a consistent pattern that started with the first meetings with Europeans, was present in the treaty period, and continued since. The paper follows, for the first time, the trail of correspondence which reveals the Indigenous origin of the treaty process. It argues that the HBC found it expedient to make “land purchase agreements” to avoid resistance from its Indigenous owners. While Indigenous parties insisted on the need for Europeans to get their permission to settle or mine their territories, the oral treaties agreed to by Indigenous groups were dramatically different from what appears in the textual versions.

Author Biographies

John Sutton Lutz, University of Victoria Law

John Sutton Lutz is a professor of history at the University of Victoria.

Graham Brazier, Independent Scholar

Graham Brazier is editor of the Fort Victoria Journal <https://www.fortvictoriajournal.ca/> the author of "Land First Nations, James Douglas and the Background to Treaty Making on Vancouver Island," in the collection of essays of which he was a co-editor Peter Cook et al, To Share Not Surrender: Indigenous and Settler Visions of Treaty Making in the Colonies of Vancouver Island and British Columbia (UBC 2021) and several articles in BC History.  He is an independent scholar living on Denman Island.

Published

18-11-2026

How to Cite

Lutz, J. S., & Brazier, G. (2026). “They Would Not Permit us to Work the Coals”: Indigenous Origins of Treaty Making on Canada’s West Coast. BC Studies: The British Columbian Quarterly, (231), 9–39. https://doi.org/10.14288/bcs.no231.201703

Issue

Section

Articles